REPORTS

06 Oct 2011

Report by the Energy Community Secretariat on Dispute Settlement

On the occassion of the 9th Ministerial Council, the Secretariat prepared its latest report on the pending dispute cases. Since the adoption of the Dispute Settlement Rules, the Secretariat has, as of 31 July 2011, received six complaints by private bodies. Upon receiving a complaint, the Secretariat assesses the merits of a case and decides whether to initiate a formal (preliminary) procedure. So far, the Secretariat has done that in two cases, namely Case ECS-2/08 against the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and Case ECS-3/08 against Serbia.

 

On 21 September 2010, the Secretariat sent, on its own motion, an Opening Letter to Bosnia and Herzegovina in Case ECS-1/10. In the Opening Letter, the Secretariat takes the preliminary view that Bosnia and Herzegovina failed to fulfill its obligations under the Energy Community Treaty by not adopting legislation prohibiting State aid and enforcing that prohibition, as required by Articles 6 and 18 of the Energy Community Treaty.

 

On 20 January 2011, the Energy Community Secretariat sent Opening Letters to Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Montenegro and Serbia in Cases ECS-1–6/11. The Secretariat contends that these six Contracting Parties have not yet adopted a common coordinated congestion management method and procedure for the allocation of capacity to the market.

 

On 8 February 2011, the Secretariat sent an Opening Letter to UNMIK  in Case ESC 7/11. In the Opening Letter, the Secretariat takes the preliminary view that UNMIK failed to fulfill its obligations under the Energy Community Treaty by not adopting legislation prohibiting State aid and enforcing that prohibition, as required by Articles 6 and 18 of the Energy Community Treaty.

 

 

 


24 Sep 2010

Report by the Energy Community Secretariat on Dispute Settlement

At the 8th Ministerial Council in Skopje, the Secretariat presented its dispute settlement report for the year 2009-2010. Out of the five filled cases, the Case ECS-1/08 against Bosnia and Herzegovina could be closed already in informal way. Whilst the Case ECS-2/08 against former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia is at an advanced procedural stage, the Secretariat will make further action as regards the "spinn off" Cases ECS-4/08 and ECS-1/09 depending the resolution of Case ECS-2/08. Case ECS-3/08 against the Republic of Serbia is still at the informal stage.

 

At the Jun 2010 PHLG, the Secretariat announced that it "will make use of the dispute settlement mechanism to address cases of non compliance, in particular with respect to market opening, price regulation and barriers to trade.” A number of cases in this respect are currently under assessment and may be expected to lead to Opening Letters within the following months.

 


 


Dec 2009

Report by the Energy Community Secretariat on Dispute Settlement

One and half years after the adoption of the Dispute Settlement Rules, the Secretariat presented its first report on the development of the dispute settlement procedure at the Dec 2009  Ministerial Council. Based on the Secretariat's assessment, the adoption of the Dispute Settlement Rules has had an immediate impact. The Secretariat has, as of 15 October 2009, received five complaints by private bodies.


Upon receiving a complaint, the Secretariat assesses the merits of a case and decides whether to initiate a formal (preliminary) procedure. So far, the Secretariat has done that in one case (Case ECS-2/08). Before initiating a procedure, however, the Secretariat will sound out possible solutions to the case in an informal way.

 

For further details on the nature of the filed cases, please, refer to report below.

 

 back|top